Common Misconceptions About Social Media Background Checks

Social media has become an integral part of our lives, shaping how we connect, communicate, and present ourselves. With so much personal information online, it's no surprise that social media background checks are increasingly used by employers, landlords, and others to gain insight into someone's character. However, there are several misconceptions surrounding these checks, from what they can reveal to how they are conducted. Let’s explore and debunk some of the most common myths to help you better understand how social media screenings really work.

1. Misconception: Social Media Checks Are Illegal

Reality: Reviewing publicly available social media content is legal. Employers and background screening companies are permitted to view anything that has been posted publicly. However, there are legal limitations such as accessing private accounts without consent or using information related to protected characteristics (like religion, race, or gender) to make decisions. These actions can violate anti-discrimination laws and regulations like the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

2. Misconception: They Only Check Facebook or Twitter

Reality: A social media background check can cover a wide range of platforms beyond just Facebook or Twitter. It may include LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok, Reddit, YouTube, and even other forums or blogs. Anything that appears in public search results or is connected to your name can be reviewed.

3. Misconception: Deleted Posts Can’t Be Found

Reality: Deleting a post doesn’t guarantee it’s completely gone. Archived versions of web pages, cached copies, and screenshots taken by others can still make deleted content accessible. While it’s good practice to clean up your online presence, don’t assume that removing posts erases them from view entirely.

4. Misconception: Only Executives Are Screened

Reality: Social media background checks are not limited to high-level positions. Many employers now review social media profiles for all applicants, including those applying for entry-level roles, internships, or freelance work especially for positions where customer interaction, brand representation, or access to sensitive information are involved.

5. Misconception: Social Media Checks Are Always Objective

Reality: Even with the best intentions, social media checks can sometimes be subjective. Tone, humor, or sarcasm may be misinterpreted, and context can be overlooked. To avoid bias, it’s important for companies to follow standardized guidelines and have trained professionals conducting these reviews.

6. Misconception: You Can’t Influence What They Find

Reality: While you can't completely erase your past online activity, you can certainly manage your digital presence. Regularly review your privacy settings, remove or hide potentially problematic content, and cultivate a positive image on professional networks like LinkedIn. The more intentional you are with your online presence, the better your chances of leaving a favorable impression.

7. Misconception: Social Media Checks Replace Traditional Background Checks

Reality: Social media screenings are intended to complement, not replace, traditional background checks. Employers still rely on checks for criminal records, employment history, and credit reports (in some cases). Social media provides additional context but does not replace the essential information from more formal background checks.

Best Practices for Social Media Screening

Establish clear, documented policies for social media background checks. Define what information is pertinent for hiring. Specify which platforms to review, what behaviors are concerning, and how findings will influence decisions.

Utilize third-party screening services for optimal results. They reduce bias, ensure legal compliance, and provide consistent findings. These services focus on job-relevant information and exclude protected class details. Learn more about our Social KYC services for identity verification.

Maintain detailed records for every social media search. Document:

• The date of the search
  
  
• Platforms checked
  
  
• Information found
  
  
• Impact on hiring decisions
  
  

Communicate openly with candidates about social media screening. Inform them:

• That it is part of the hiring process
  
  
• Which platforms will be checked
  
  
• How findings could affect their application
  
  
• Their rights regarding the results
  
  

These practices protect both employers and candidates and ensure a fair hiring process. Update policies regularly to stay current with new platforms and regulations.

Legal Considerations and Compliance

Social media background checks must adhere to strict legal guidelines. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) prohibits discrimination based on protected traits found through social media. Employers cannot make decisions based on race, religion, national origin, gender, disability, or age seen in social posts.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) requires employers to:

• Obtain written consent before checks
  
  
• Provide report copies if requested
  
  
• Follow procedures when rejecting candidates
  
  

State laws impose additional regulations. Some states restrict:

• Requesting passwords
  
  
• Forcing candidates to friend employers
  
  
• Using personal social media in hiring
  
  

Protected class information presents challenges. Screening must avoid:

• Religious affiliations
  
  
• Political views
  
  
• Medical details
  
  
• Family status
  
  
• Sexual orientation
  
  

Phyllo advises partnering with skilled screening providers familiar with these regulations. They filter out protected information and deliver reports focused on job-related behavior, reducing legal risks while maintaining effective screening.

How Phyllo Can Help

For businesses looking to streamline the process of social media background checks and ensure they’re gathering accurate, verified data, Phyllo offers a powerful solution. Phyllo’s platform enables companies to securely access verified data from social media and other digital sources. It helps remove the guesswork by providing businesses with reliable insights that are compliant with privacy and data protection regulations. This ensures that companies can make informed, objective decisions based on data that’s not only relevant but also trusted.

Conclusion

Social media background checks are a valuable tool for understanding someone’s digital footprint, but it's important to dispel the misconceptions that often surround them. When conducted responsibly and ethically, these checks offer insight while maintaining fairness and respect for privacy. Understanding how they work and what they don’t do helps both employers and individuals make informed decisions in today’s digital landscape.

FAQs

1. Are social media background checks legal?

Yes, they are legal as long as they involve publicly available information. However, accessing private accounts without permission or making decisions based on protected characteristics (such as religion, race, gender, etc.) can violate anti-discrimination laws and privacy regulations.

2. What platforms are typically included in a social media background check?

Checks may include major platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok, and YouTube, as well as blogs, forums, and other public online content. Any publicly accessible information linked to your name can potentially be reviewed.

3. Can deleted posts still show up in a background check?

Yes, deleted posts may still exist in web archives, cached pages, screenshots, or third-party platforms. Deletion doesn’t always mean complete removal, so it’s important to be mindful of what’s posted in the first place.

4. Are social media checks only used for high-level positions?

No, many employers conduct social media screenings for all levels, including internships and freelance roles. These checks are especially common for positions that involve public interaction or represent a company’s brand.

5. Do social media background checks replace traditional background checks?

Not at all. Social media checks are typically used to complement traditional checks such as employment verification, criminal record history, and education credentials. They add context, not hard data.

6. Can someone control or influence the outcome of their social media background check?

Yes, individuals can manage their digital presence by adjusting privacy settings, removing questionable content, and maintaining professional profiles on platforms like LinkedIn. Proactive online reputation management can make a big difference.

‍